June 3, 2017

The 5 Best Feather Pillows Reviews 2018(Including Buying Guide)

It is imperative that you stay attentive while buying a pillow as it will be responsible for a comfortable sleep. Many people believe that feather and down pillows are the sole choices for sleeping. You can go through this article for the best feather pillows reviews.

Most feather pillows have a combination stuffing of feathers and down and both of these are different. Down is basically the small, soft, baby feathers, newly growing belonging to goose or duck. And the fully grown feathers are the second important component.

Obviously, the feathers used as stuffing poke out of pillows commonly as they have hard quill point and shaft. It is rare that a feather is filled with feathers only, there will be some down. The ratio you want completely depends on you, as many choices are available in the retail and online market.

A 50-50 filling composition is mostly preferred. If the volume of down is more, the chances of a feather poking out are lower. Some people do consider a feather poking out as good luck and they make a wish on it.

Our Recommendation

Pillows with a higher composition of feathers become heavier as the percentage of feathers increases in them. Down is lighter, fluffier and softer in comparison but there are fill power options to choose from. According to the fill quantity selected, the pillow would be firm, medium, soft, etc.

Each manufacturer will have their own version of fluff and comfort level concerning their feather pillows. The level of firmness or softness will vary with each manufacturer and the diverse pillows that they make. We have compiled a list of the top 5 feather pillows according to customer reviews to help you make the final choice.

Our personal favorite is the Down & Feather Original Medium Feather Pillow that comes in one standard size. The comfort varies depending upon the fill and weight of the pillow with a standard size of 26” X 20”. You have three density options, with the fill capacity options of 20, 16, and 12 oz.

You can select from the firm, medium, and soft density fills according to your sleeping position (side, back or stomach). The price is genuine and the pillow will last for many years. However, you will have to buy a cover for this pillow that can be washed when required.

Table of Comparison




​Rating (1-5)

best feather pillows reviews

  • Maximum Weight (approx.): 1.3 pounds
  • Dimensions: 26” X 20” X 5”
  • Size / Shape: One size Rectangular (Standard)

Rating: 5.0/5.0

Bed of Roses down Feather Pillow

  • Maximum Weight (approx.): 3 pounds
  • Dimensions: 22” X 22” X 9”
  • Size / Shape: Square (Standard)

Rating: 4.3/5.0

ComfyDown Feather Pillow

  • Maximum Weight (approx.): 6 pounds
  • Dimensions: 24” X 24” X 10”
  • Size / Shape: Square (Standard)

Rating: 4.2/5.0

Puredown White Goose Feather Bed Pillow

  • Maximum Weight (approx.): 4.4, 5.7 pounds
  • Dimensions: 20” X 28” X 2”, 20” X 36” X 2”
  • Size / Shape: Standard Queen, King

Rating: 4.5/5.0

Topsleepy Goose Feather Filling Pillows

  • Maximum Weight (approx.): 8 pounds
  • Dimensions: 30” X 20” X 7”
  • Size / Shape: Queen

Rating: 4.2/5.0

Best Feather Pillows to Buy – Top 5

1. Down & Feather Original Medium Feather Pillow

The Original Feather Pillow by Down & Feather Co. is a guaranteed hypoallergenic product that is manufactured in America. This all-feather pillow is stuffed with high-quality 22 oz. feathers of Hungarian Goose. The wrap is 220 thread counts, 100% cotton, white and blue stripped shell sealed with unique edge knife stitching.

Mash or fold this original feather pillow into the perfect shape you want for the required support. Give it your own unique personality and shape as you replace your 20 or even 40 years old pillow. Your old pillow would obviously have broken in and become soft due to decades of employment.

So a new feather pillow will demand a little patience and love from you with some time to break in. But once you get used to the Original Feather Pillow, there is no going back. This pillow has 3 levels of density options or fill, namely 20, 16 or 12 oz.

The 20 oz is the firmest feather pillow; regardless this pillow is great for side sleepers. You get the special “Perfect Pillow Policy” facilitating free density adjustment up to one level within a year from purchase. As a straight spine ensures the correct posture and comfortable sleep, this pillow ensures just that.

2. Bed of Roses down Feather Pillow

With a strong wholly cotton protective cover of 233 thread count, this pillow has 95% feathers of grey ducks. The other 5% fill is soft duck down giving the pillow a perfect amount of fluffiness. These square pillow inserts by Bed of Roses will soon become your favorite comforters.

The dimensions of this square feather pillow are 22” X 22” with a thickness of about 9 inches. A single pillow weighs approximately 3 pounds while you can buy it online as a set of two as well. A cushion cover of 20” side would be the perfect cover for these feather pillows keeping them fluffy.

The maximum amount of feathers ensures that you can fold or shape the pillow as you want. Since the pillow is square shaped, it is great as a sofa cushion but can be used wherever you want. The size is standard and big enough to go with almost anything.

95% is high when it comes to feathers and you will encounter many sudden poking feathers at all time. A great low priced feather pillow alternative and you get a set of two. Use them absolutely anywhere from sofa cushions to bed pillows to travel pillows.

3. ComfyDown Feather Pillow

Another 95% feather filled pillow alternative is this ComfyDown product with only 5% down. The pillow cover is made of 233 thread count 100% cotton fabric with stitching that is down-proof. The feathers will not poke out of this stitching, so you get a premium quality product at a great price.

Pillows such as this one are meant for indoor use only and a new pillow requires repeating this process. Doing so will guarantee a longer life and a constant fully plump look. These pillows are manufactured fully in the United States of America and have the best feather pillows reviews.

Feather pillows are hypoallergenic and they will not absorb heat in summers as air circulates through them easily. This particular pillow is more on the firm side due to its excessive but just the perfect amount of filling. In case you will be using them for sleeping, it will be more suitable for back or side sleepers.

These huge square feather pillows will require constant fluffing as they flatten out easily and quickly. Some isolated cases of foul-smelling pillows have been reported by customers. But, the customer service is great and most of these pillows were replaced.

4. Puredown White Goose Feather Bed Pillow

Double layers of cotton fabric cover made of 233 thread count and a peach skin lining to evade poking feathers. The filling is 90% feathers of white goose and 10% down from white goose. It is available in two size options, standard (queen) and king size with the same 2-inch thickness.

For a cozy, restful sleep the 32 oz and 42 oz filling of queen and king respectively should be enough. They have varying dimensions but this pillow should be preferred by back and stomach sleepers. Read the instructions for washing and care, they can be washed and dried in machines but carefully.

If you are looking for feather pillows that are not overly fluffy, this is the one for you. The thickness is less as compared to others, but you get a large sized pillow for your bedroom or couch. A thick pillow cover is recommended to ensure that those occasional poking feathers do not irritate your skin.

The White Goose PureDown pillow is sold on Amazon only by PureDown itself; any other seller is most probably fake. You get each pillow individually packed in a sealed fresh PVC bag. You get them in a set of two and the price is very reasonable for such good quality.

5. Topsleepy Goose Feather Filling Pillows

Crushed goose feather and down filling packed in a 300 thread count Satin Cotton fabric could be perfect for you. The filling is mostly crushed feathers with a little ratio of goose down making a premium Topsleepy product. They pay attention to small details such as using the same fabric, clever adornment, embroidered, computerized and firmly locked.

You get complete support from the edges of the pillow as they will not completely taper and flatten. It is a preferred choice for people who indulge in mental labor, also great for cervical and shoulder vertebra. The pillow has a skin friendly protective cover which is a natural fabric protecting from skin allergies.

It is recommended for back and side sleepers as they will get good support for their neck. Do not wash it in the machine; instead, use lukewarm water for spot cleaning but avoid direct sunlight. Hang it to dry and regardless do this repeatedly as sunlight and airing will keep it refreshed and revitalized.

For storage, keep the pillow in a duvet cover or breathable bag in a dry and cool place. This would protect the pillow from moisture and insects. For thorough cleaning consult a local dry cleaning expert, proper care will ensure that you get required support from the pillow.

Buying Guide

You cannot buy a pillow for yourself based on someone else’s experience, it has to be your decision. Otherwise, you might realize later that you bought the wrong pillow. Each person has very specific and particular needs when it comes to the support and comfort of a pillow.

So, what do you need to take into consideration while deciding about the pillow that would be perfect?

1) Dimensions

A square feather pillow is more suited for a couch while a rectangular one for beds or comforters. Think about the size of the pillow you require, exactly how big do you need?

Most pillows are sold without pillow covers or shams. You can buy the designs you like or you might already have covers matching with your bed sheets. Buy a cover/sham that is 1 or 2 inches smaller, so that the pillow fits in perfectly and remains fluffy.

2) Pillow Fill & Weight

What ratio of feathers and down are you looking for? A feather pillow will have more structure while more down means more fluffiness. What you want entirely depends on your needs.

The weight of a pillow increases with the amount of stuffing in it. More stuffing obviously leads to a better structure and it maintains its own shape. They will require constant fluffing and airing.

3) Price

Establish a budget before hand. One you know the amount you can spend, it will narrow down your choices. You will look for pillows in that range only.

4) Style of Sleeping

Are you are back sleeper or stomach sleeper? The structure and thickness of a pillow you require will depend on your sleeping position.

If you sleep on your side, get a thick and high weight pillow that it firm and holds its shape. A back sleeper can opt for medium while stomach sleepers should go for soft, competitively thin pillows.


Feather pillows are conventionally used by many households and commercial facilities. Although, various artificial fills have replaced the natural feather filling but it is still the choice of many. Feather pillows are hypoallergenic and have various benefits in the long run. You can find some feather bed topper here to go with your feather pillow.

The 5 products listed here are pillows with the best feather pillows reviews. But our favorite is the Down & Feather Original Medium Feather Pillow that is available in three options. You can choose from firm medium or soft fill with 20 oz, 16 or 12 oz. capacity respectively.

If you are buying a pillow online, it is recommended that you do a complete research about the manufacturer. Make an informed decision. We expect that this article was helpful and you will share it further.

For other recommendations have a look at our best down pillows reviews.

    Caryn Agnes

    Click Here to Leave a Comment Below

    Leave a Reply: